image

  • Another expression of rereading

    • It is easy to assume that “same” and “not match the correct (answer, etc.)” are incompatible, but this is because it is assumed that X and Y are a single point, and if both are set, a situation can arise where “the set is not equal, but is largely overlap’ situation can occur if both are set. In that case, if you focus on the common part, they are ‘the same’, and if you focus on the rest, they are ‘different’.
  • When we say, “X is Y (the same as) Y,” we are thinking “X=Y” if we consider X and Y as a single symbol.

  • However, if the assumption of a single point is incorrect,

    • If X or Y is a set
  • There could be a discrepancy between X and Y.

  • In that case, it is compatible for X to be (nearly) the same as Y and for there to be a difference between X and Y.

  • It is not “the same,” but “the sets overlap significantly,” or, to put it more softly, “[Similar.

2022-02-17 Changed title from “Same and different have the same root” to “Same and different are compatible”


This page is auto-translated from /nishio/「同じ」と「違う」は両立する using DeepL. If you looks something interesting but the auto-translated English is not good enough to understand it, feel free to let me know at @nishio_en. I’m very happy to spread my thought to non-Japanese readers.